When Al Franken started running for the U.S. Senate in Minnesota, a lot of Minnesotans worried he would embarrass them by becoming the class clown of the Senate. Franken had been silly-to-outrageous as a comedian, talk radio host, and author, so Minnesotans understandably worried he would be a goofball as a senator as well.
But Franken ran a serious-minded campaign, narrowly defeated then-Senator Norm Coleman, and, according to polls, has won over many voters since then.
How did Franken convert the skeptics? As a Senator, Franken hasn’t been the class clown. In fact, he has been the class nerd, serious as a heart attack, even by stoic Minnesotan standards. Franken has bent over backwards to show that he takes his job seriously, and he has had some serious legislative victories on important but obscure policy issues, such medical loss ratios, diabetes prevention, and promotion of agricultural energy technologies.
To paraphrase Franken’s Saturday Night Live character Stuart Smalley, Senator Franken has proven to Minnesotans that he’s “good enough” and “smart enough.” But when it comes to likability, sometimes it’s difficult for Minnesotans to warm up to Franken, simply because they don’t see his less serious side very often.
Being perceived as too serious is perhaps a good problem to have for a recovering comedian. But it could pose a bit of a political challenge as Franken prepares to connect with voters during a reelection fight in a difficult year for Democrats. After all, this is the same state that elected the cartoonish Jesse Ventura, in part because Ventura’s humorous debate appearances helped Minnesota voters relate to him on a personal level.
Having proven that he can be serious and effective, I think Minnesotans now would be okay if Franken showed a bit of his humorous side more often. He shouldn’t return to SNL or Air America form, but he could occassionally lighten it up. After all, many serious-minded congressional leaders have shown that serious legislating and humor can go together.
“It’s a great country, where anyone can grow up to be President…except me.” – Senator Barry Goldwater (R-AZ)
“They appear to have become so attached to their outrage that they are even more outraged that they won’t be able to be outraged anymore.” Representative Barney Frank (D-MA)
“We have the same percentage of lightweights in Congress as you have in your hometown. After all, it’s representative government. Senator Alan Simpson (R-WY)
“I’ve never really warmed up to television and, in fairness to television, it’s never warmed up to me.” Senator Walter Mondale (D-MN)
“The difference between a caucus and a cactus is that the cactus has the pricks on the outside.” Representative Mo Udall (D-AZ)
Meanwhile comedian Al Franken is here to tell us:
“Antitrust enforcement has always been more effective at stopping horizontal integration…than it has at this kind of vertical integration.”
A New York Times headline recently noted Franken’s earnest dive into the complex Comcast-Time Warner merger is “No Joke.” Don’t we know it. When the subject turns to the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890, Franken’s eyes light up. Most Minnesotans’ eyes glaze over.
I wholeheartedly applaud the studiousness and work ethic that Franken is bringing to his Senate duties. In an age when self-serving circus ponies like Michele Bachmann can’t stop posing for the cameras long enough to accomplish anything for the people they serve, Congress needs more work horses like Franken to do the thoughtful legislating.
That focus on legislative plodding really does impact the lives of ordinary Americans. For example, Franken’s “medical loss ratio” legislative victory may not make for scintillating water cooler discussions, but it is helping taxpayers save a remarkable $4 billion per year. That’s billion with a “b.” Unsung policy accomplishments like this are why I am thrilled to have Senator Serious representing me.
Still, debates aren’t only impacted by persistence and process mastery. Congressional leaders like Bob Dole and Mo Udall proved that debates also can be informed and shaped by judicious use of humor. Like Dole and Udall, Senator Franken has a special gift that all too few of his congressional colleagues possess. After he is given a well-earned reelection victory, here’s hoping he feels more free to use it.
– Loveland
Note: This post was featured as a “best of the best” by MinnPost’s Blog Cabin.