Now that we’ve all had a good, hard-earned laugh at the mug shot of Fulton County perp #P01135809, we should probably turn to a discussion of the unlikelihood that convicted or not that glowering fool will never see the inside of a prison cell. If you’ve followed the game of scandal-mired high-profile politicians you know as well as I do that there’s an industry around them to prevent them from enduring the indignities of justice that would befall you, me and any platinum-selling rap star.
But nefarious scheming withstanding, its possible to foresee a scenario where Joe Biden might agree to pardon Trump, for the simple reason of finally and fully excising a festering tumor from the public corpus.
Sounds crazy, I know. But hear me out.
I couldn’t bear to watch more than five minutes of Trump’s Twitter/X interview with Tucker Carlson. (Someone tell me if Carlson ever reminded Trump to his face how much he hated him.) But the snippet I endured showed me a tired, flabby, addled old man with no coherent thought in his head other than mewling — on and on — about how unfair everything and everyone has been to him. “Standard Trump”, you say. But the fatigue in his face and posture was what was striking. The guy is exhausted.
As many have said, Trump is running again purely to return to the Oval Office and pardon himself. He’s never had any policy goals, other than wreaking havoc on his enemies, so why assume now that he’s got some big “to do” list, you know “infrastructure week 7.0” or “repealing Obamacare” or … oh, hell, why even bother … he doesn’t care about anything other than self-preservation. And by that I mean not sharing cell bunk with Big Louie or some MS 13 gangster.
This then is where “The Art of the Deal”, to borrow a phrase, steps in. Given his unpardonable exposure in Georgia, Trump’s only true all-purpose Get Out of Jail Free card is a grand, overarching plea deal with … the Biden administration. A deal that pardons him for all his federal crimes, criminal and civil accrued to date and in the future, plus … plus … a coordinated arrangement with Fulton County/Georgia to waive detention in that case. All in exchange for dropping out of the 2024 race, never again running for public office and just basically shutting the f*ck up, under penalty of voiding the deal and reinstituting every sentence he faces if he screws up.
In other words, “Go back to one of your goddam golf clubs and disappear. And by that we mean don’t stick your jowly orange mug up over the privet hedges ever again.”
The viability in this idea rests in Trump taking seriously his attorneys’ counsel that he stands a near 100% likelihood of being convicted on at least one of the 91 counts against him. (Jesus Christ, man! 91!)
Conviction on something, and maybe a lot of somethings, is nigh on as likely as the sun rising tomorrow over ex-wife Ivanka’s unmowed grave. And conviction is far more likely and certain than him winning another election against Joe Biden.
No one seems to doubt Trump’s had the idea of a plea deal presented to him by one or more of the semi-legitimate lawyers who have passed through his gilded office doors.
But, you ask, “Why would Biden do this? His chances of reelection are far better facing Trump than just about anyone else currently in the race.”
And that’s true, if you accept conventional wisdom, which I do. Obviously, as a gift to the country, a deal that removes Trump and all his relentless bullshit from the media marketplace with the stroke of pen, is an unalloyed public good. But politics are politics. So the strategizing from Biden and the government is how and when to float the deal that best minimizes the ability of the Republicans to prop up an effective alternative.
That moment is certainly not now or any time before next spring’s primary season has run its course. But what about — just spitballing here — right after the Republicans anoint him anew in Milwaukee next summer?
More sage heads than mine will argue that the “excitement” of a new, fresh GOP nominee — perhaps an annoying, jabbering tech bro, a woman who is more weather vane than serious administrator, or a pious ex-talk show host-turned-veep who they tried to lynch a couple years ago, take your pick — would push anyone of them over the top against “Sleepy Joe” and his “crippling inflation” and “crime infested blue cities”. For that kind of thinking, the risk is too high.
But what percentage of the MAGA cult, deprived of their 6’3″ 215, Muhammed Ali-in-his-prime thought leader, might simply stay home? Would their evaporation out balance the “normie” suburban Republicans who’d come flowing back, relieved not to have to vote for an exhausting fat fraud/rapist/coup leader?
No one knows. But $50 says both camps, Trump’s and Biden’s have given thought to how to make this happen.
The other possibility: A civil-liberties irony:
The currently constituted Supreme Court reverses Giuliani’s (and Trump’s) convictions because RICO criminalizes otherwise legal “overt acts.”
I’m reading this late in bed here. Your descriptive writing is giving me many giggles. Especially orange guy peeking over the shrubs.
But I thank you. Love your insightful theories/ possibilities. Please let him go back to Mar-a-lago never to be heard of again. Brother Bob is happy your back in all your colorful glory!
I will vote against any president who pardons another president.
The fate of Gerald Ford — another Watergate echo.
Wow, that is a hot take. Fun, thought-provoking read. My reckless speculation follows:
Though unlikely, I think there is a slight possibility that Biden could pardon Trump, but I think it would most likely come after the 2024 general election, not before.
Reasons for Biden pardoning Trump: 1) Biden’s has a strong instinct to try to unite and heal a dangerously divided nation, and perhaps avoid a cycle of ad hoc retributive violence somewhat akin to Ireland’s The Troubles, and he wants that to be his historical legacy; 2) Concern that the spectacle of jailing Trump could fuel an endless future cycle of criminal indictments against every future presidential incumbent; and 3) Prove to American centrists and others around the world that Biden didn’t “jail his political opponent to retain power,” something that Biden doesn’t want to unfairly be the thing for which he is most remembered.
Reasons for that timing: 1) Team Biden thinks Trump is the most beatable Republican in 2024 so they want to wait until Biden wins the general before a pardon; 2) Team Biden thinks pardoning Trump could jeopardize Biden’s chances of being elected in 2024 (e.g. loss of Trump-hating liberals and Never Trumpers to a third party candidate or just driving those folks to stay home and sit out the 2024 general election) and wants to wait until Trump is a lame duck before he takes that political hit.
Well, I think it’s a (very) long shot. But … at some point someone in Trump Legal World will feel out the Justice Department on a plea deal. Just to completely understand what the terms might be. Whatever Justice says, one way or another, the White House will be informed. Purely as a thought experiment, what do we think would be apprpriate terms for a Trump pardon? What would he have to agree to? A public, televised statement admitting it was all bullshit? An utter lie? And then a kind of gilded house arrest in Mar a Lago? And as I say, someone in Biden Land has thought through this scenario and come up with terms of their own.
One additional point–I think that it would make sense to pardon Trump after 2 things happen:
1. He loses the election
2. He is convicted in Federal court
(remember that Biden can’t pardon the Fulton County stuff….)